“Do not cast me off for what I have done but strive to save me in the church” — William Smith1
In 1835, William Smith held several sessions of an informal debating society/club—something that initially was seen as an opportunity for spirited learning and guidance by the Holy Spirit. However, tensions escalated in the third meeting, ultimately leading to a heated argument between Joseph and William.
Joseph Smith Sr. tried to mediate, but the argument turned physical when William lunged at Joseph, who was trying to remove his coat and became entangled. William struck Joseph repeatedly, exacerbating an old injury Joseph had sustained during a previous assault. The altercation ended with Joseph incapacitated on the floor and only stopped when others intervened.
In the aftermath, a remorseful William penned a heartfelt apology to Joseph, expressing regret and questioning his worthiness as a member of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles. He pleaded for forgiveness and requested to be released from his duties, fearing his actions had made him unfit to serve. Joseph, touched by his brother's contrition, responded with a message of reconciliation, hoping to restore their relationship and forget the past.2
